Using
data is an essential skill in 21st-Century journalism. This
handout helps you to learn more about the data sources on your
beat and how to access and use them. It was compiled by Steve
Buttry, Writing Coach, Omaha World-Herald, and reporters
Paul Goodsell, Joe Kolman, Nichole Aksamit and Cindy Gonzalez
for a workshop at the World-Herald, Oct. 23, 2002.
|
|
Mining the Data
on Your Beat
No competent reporter
would consider doing the job without knowing how to interview or take
notes or to dig for records. In 21st-Century journalism, using data is
not a specialized skill. It's an essential skill. Whatever your level
of ability, you should seek to learn more about the data sources on your
beat and how to access and use them.
- Ask for electronic
records.
When an agency you cover releases a report or some annual statistics,
ask for the report on disk or CD or as an e-mail attachment. We can
incur significant expenses when we ask public agencies to sort data
for us (though often much less than they might tell you initially).
But every report already exists in an electronic file that should be
easy and cheap to obtain. If you provide the disk, it shouldn't cost
anything. Whether you use the data immediately or not, we should have
it on hand electronically.
- Pursue the data.
Ask for data as aggessively as you insist on access to any other public
record. You must not be intimidated when it comes to asking for electronic
information. When someone cites facts in an interview, you already are
used to asking, "How do you know that?" and asking for copies
of any reports the source is citing. Ask for an electronic copy as well.
Often the source would rather e-mail you the report rather than find
an envelope anyway. Don't ask just for the report itself, but for the
data on which it was based.
- Consider different
uses.
As you learn about data sources, consider what stories you might pursue
based primarily on this data. Consider how you might use this data for
information to support other stories you might do. Consider how you
might use the data routinely. Consider how the data might be useful
to colleagues on other beats.
- Use the Internet.
Visit the Web sites of public agencies and private organizations on
your beat and learn what data sources are available readily online.
Learn what reports and statistics are posted online. Learn whether the
agencies post searchable databases online or pdf files that are more
cumbersome to use online (but might identify electronic records you
could obtain to sort and search yourself). Browse the databases to learn
what information they offer and consider how that information might
be useful in stories.
- Get budgets.
Obtain the budgets and spending records of public agencies in electronic
form so you can use a spreadsheet to look for trends, changes, irregularities.
- Get directories.
Learn what sort of basic information the agencies on your beat might
have in electronic form: personnel rosters, payroll records, government
board rosters.
Get an updated version of the payroll records periodically -- say quarterly
-- and you'll have a good way of tracking government raises. It's searchable
and, thus, a nice way to double-check a name spelling and job title
and salary, a good way to know who's been with the city the longest
and who's a newbie, an easy way to access a list of the city's highest
and lowest-paid employees. It's particularly useful when a city employee
makes other news -- gets arrested or fired or wins an award -- or when
you are just searching for an employee who might have been around during
a particular time period or has experience in a given area.
- Listen for data
behind statistics.
When sources tell you they are tracking or studying something -- a certain
kind of complaint, the condition of city roads, housing code violations,
etc. -- chances are they are working from a database or a spreadsheet.
Ask "How do you know that noise complaints have risen or that 65
percent of the streets are in good condition?" and then ask to
see their work, which may prompt other stories.
- Interview the
data.
Think of data as another source that you interview. Do you want to know
how many single mothers of a particular race live in North Omaha? You
could probably call a number of people and get some vague answers and
some anecdotal sense of whether the number is growing or declining,
but why not ask the Census? Think of questons you could ask the data
on your beat: What bar has the most liquor law violations? What school
has the best test scores? What intersection has the most accidents?
- Study the data
first.
Reporters are at such an advantage when they go into an interview knowing
at least something, and sometimes a lot, about the information the source
deals with. If you can find some data online or in a database we already
have in the newsroom, check that before you interview a source. It helps
you ask better questions and helps you catch the source in mistakes
or lies.
- Organize with
spreadsheets.
A spreadsheet helps you understand information. You spot relationships,
trends, reversals, gaps. You can use a spreadsheet for something as
simple as a source list or chronology, or to analyze thousands of pieces
of data.
- Enter data yourself.
Sure, it's nice to get data e-mailed to you, but don't forget that you
can enter data yourself. Often an afternoon at a courthouse or government
office searching through paper records yields a notebook full of information
you can analyze and understand better if you take a few hours to enter
it in a spreadsheet.
- Use Outlook.
Even if you can't get Excel on your computer, at least make full use
of Outlook. That's a database of sources and dates that will help you
get used to entering and searching for data. Learn the different ways
you can use Outlook and organize at least your source files to make
them fully searchable.
- Use Census data.
Census data are not just the basis for Census stories, but provide helpful
information about families, housing, economics and communities. Go to
http://www.census.gov/
and on the home page, you see a place where you can enter your state
and get specific data for a state. On the page for that state, you can
choose a county and get more specific data. The home page for the Census
also has a topical index to still more reports.
- Seek federal
data.
If you're working on a story that might have federal data, check out
http://www.firstgov.gov.
It has a search engine that goes through all federal agencies and another
that goes through the states. If, for instance you want the Office of
blah blah blah, but you don't know what division of what federal agency
it's buried in, this will pull it up. It's also good for pulling up
documents and stats.
- Seek state data.
If you want state data for Nebraska, check out http://www.nitc.state.ne.us/itc/sg.htm.
It has an incredible wealth of information. It lists the Information
Technology plans for most of Nebraska's state agencies. The value in
it is that the agencies list all the information they keep on databases
and what format it is in. So instead of calling and asking the fire
marshal if he had a database of fireworks dealers and what was in it,
you call him and say you want a copy of the Access database for all
fireworks dealers. (When Joe did this, he actually said he didn't know
if they had such a thing, and Joe pointed him to their IT plan). Just
flipping through it will give anyone a bunch of ideas. For instance,
the governor's office keeps track of everyone who contacts him and what
they wanted in an Access database. For "security" reasons,
they've made the list more difficult to search, but we have a paper
copy, or you can read through the full pdf file that's still at the
Web site. Every state and government entity had to make such a list
for Y2K preparations. The agency in your beat probably has one.
- Think critically
about data.
Joe has this quote from Dick O'Reilly of the LA Times taped to his desk:
"The most important lessons in CAR are not which keys to push on
the keyboard, but how to think critically about data. People who learn
to think that way will learn which keys to push because doing so becomes
fundamental to their quests. People who only learn what keys to push
really haven't learned anything."
- Other resources
|